Underrated Milwaukee Desserts

Underrated Milwaukee Desserts

Only some American cities can compete with the buzz and appeal of New York City and its southern neighbor, Chicago. However, nestled among the Midwest’s stunning landscape lies a lesser-known gem: Milwaukee. This overlooked city may have a different glamorous reputation than the Big Apple or The Windy City. But the city is also home to some of the most unique and delicious desserts you will ever taste. Below are some underrated Milwaukee desserts from private chefs that you need to try:

Key Lime Pie 

Tarte au Citron is Milwaukee’s version of the Florida classic Key Lime Pie. This delicious dessert has been delighting the taste buds of Milwaukeeans for years. It is a classic combination of lemon and cream cheese, with a sweet graham cracker crust and a tart, citrusy finish.

The traditional recipe calls for a combination of lemon juice and zest, cream cheese, and egg whites. This mixture is then poured into a prepared graham cracker crust and baked until golden brown. The cream cheese and the sweet graham cracker crust balance the tartness of the lemon juice. The result is a delicious, citrusy dessert that is sure to please.

For decades, Tarte au Citron has been a staple at Milwaukee restaurants and bakeries. It is famous for summer gatherings, wedding receptions, and special occasions. It is also an excellent way to add a unique flavor to any meal. Whether you serve it for brunch or dinner, it will surely be a hit.

Carrot Cake

Carrot cake has been a staple in homes worldwide for generations, and Milwaukee’s private chefs have taken it to a new level. Their carrot cake recipe is a delicious, guilt-free dessert option that will satisfy any sweet tooth.

The secret to the chefs’ carrot cake is its unique blend of natural ingredients. The cake has freshly grated carrots, brown sugar, and spices. The mix of sweet and savory flavors ensures the cake is moist and flavorful. The result is a dense and delicious cake that will surely be a hit with any crowd.

The chefs also add a hint of orange zest to the cake, adding a bright citrus flavor. Adding raisins and nuts gives the cake an added crunch, making it even more enjoyable. The chefs also top their cakes with cream cheese frosting, the perfect accompaniment to the dense and flavorful cake.

Pistachio Crème Puff

If you are looking for a more decadent twist to the classic dessert of cream puffs, you want to take a tip from the private chefs in Milwaukee and try the pistachio creme puff. This tasty treat combines sweet and savory, making it an ideal dessert for any special occasion.

The pistachio creme puff is a delectable combination of a traditional cream puff pastry shell.  Chefs fill them with a light and creamy pistachio-flavored custard. The custard is made with real pistachios, giving it an irresistible nutty flavor and a hint of sweetness. The pastry is then dusted with a light coating of confectioners’ sugar, adding a touch of elegance to the presentation.

When serving the pistachio creme puff, you have a few options. It can be served on its own, with a dollop of whipped cream, or with a scoop of your favorite ice cream. You can also top it with a chocolate or caramel sauce drizzle for an even richer flavor.


Milwaukee has an array of delectable desserts that can satisfy anyone’s cravings. From the classic Tarte au Citron to the unique Carrot Cake and Pistachio Creme Puffs, these desserts will tantalize your taste buds. Whether you want something traditional or a bit more adventurous, Milwaukee has something for everyone. 

If you want to taste authentic Milwaukee desserts, book a private chef from Milwaukee to make these treats for you. You can hire one of our culinary professionals from Food Fire + Knives. Our team can whip up these decadent dishes for you and your guests, so make your reservations now!

Published By Shamira Deshpande Shamira is a passionate Social Media Manager and avid foodie who brings creativity and enthusiasm to every project. With 7+ years of experience in the social media management field, she is responsible for creative strategy development and implementation, content creation, optimizing campaigns, and analysis of social media performance for Food Fire + Knives.